Show Posts

This section allows you to view all posts made by this member. Note that you can only see posts made in areas you currently have access to.


Messages - rotiprata

Pages: [1] 2 3 ... 17
1
Feng Shui / Re: How much can you benefit from Feng Shui in apartment units?
« on: September 15, 2021, 09:03:57 PM »
[Hidden post: You need login to forum to see it.]

2
Feng Shui / Re: How much can you benefit from Feng Shui in apartment units?
« on: September 12, 2021, 08:44:44 AM »
[Hidden post: You need login to forum to see it.]

What I was saying was that when we relate the Stars to the techniques of Yi Jing and Mei Hua, we can figure out specific events to follow.

Then it becomes specific meridian, affected in specific year/month and day in specific way in a person. Can say who the person will be as well, from the people in the house.

Structures are very broad generalization and as such as subject to a lot of risks when used alone. As there are too many other factors.

I personally avoid using the structures too much, making the youtube videos 90% waste of time for me, as he seems to only be explaining structures. Since most houses and apartments we will make won't fall into any of these structures, so far there wasn't much learned that one can actually use.

Yet I'm not sure what it has to do with Purple White Script?

You reference the stars then the meridian and acknowledged their importance but yet you simply discard structures? Do you even understand what are structures and how it relates to the stars and the meridian? As above so below, this should ring a bell for any ardent star gazers.

While I'm no fan of XKFS, I do appreciate the guy's efforts and generosity in sharing. One man's meat another man's poison, but to openly expressed it as wasting your time to prove a point in an argument, that is uncalled for.

3
Feng Shui / Re: How much can you benefit from Feng Shui in apartment units?
« on: September 10, 2021, 07:39:39 PM »
[Hidden post: You need login to forum to see it.]

4
Feng Shui / Re: How much can you benefit from Feng Shui in apartment units?
« on: September 10, 2021, 06:37:47 PM »
[Hidden post: You need login to forum to see it.]

5
Feng Shui / Re: How much can you benefit from Feng Shui in apartment units?
« on: September 10, 2021, 03:36:45 PM »
I personally enjoy more scientific approach to all of this.
Purple White Script is meaningless from that point of view, so are 8 mansions.
Problem with both is that they seem heavily focusing on "Beneficial" and "Not Beneficial" without actual events they are leading to from what I remember.
Since we have so many other factors in the house acting on the"beneficial" and "not beneficial" part, added to the fact things are never as simple as "beneficial" and "not beneficial"(something may be good for wealth, bad for health, but even then it should be bad for health in specific way, affecting an element and person and in specific time etc.).

Since "beneficial" and "not beneficial" is practically meaningless in real life, both can't be tested in a reasonable enough level, making the system just a waste of time if we want scientific approach to this.

While I do enjoy Hung Hin Cheong books a lot, this specific one and the software I had to make to test it was an absolute waste of time, in my humble view. If we want to use the Doors from QMDJ, better make QMDJ chart for it instead of using some simplified calculation without good explanation what they do, as its described in the script.

In the current state for someone learning I would recommend Flying Star > XKDG / XKZR > QMDj Feng Shui from the San Yuan Feng Shui systems. While I do have to say that the last one I'm still not started heavily learning yet, but it works ok in other context, so there will be a way there.

Everything else isn't deep enough to be tested fully, so while it may work, without knowing what it actually do may be wiser to avoid in its current state. Only my view, obviously and based on the idea we want scientific approach. If we don't all is there to use, as unreliable as it may be.

The entire "Meta" physics studies are unreliable without much scientific backings to be bluntly frank. Even those whom said to be backed by empirical data with high success rate might varies miles apart within the specifics or environmental variables. Without a governing body that (which i foresee will never happen) validates submitted claims then it will never be scientifically proven.

Hence may i suggest that you are likely better of exploring stuff like quantum physics which many have relate it with Chinese "Meta"physics.

Just thinking out loud.

6
Feng Shui / Re: How much can you benefit from Feng Shui in apartment units?
« on: September 10, 2021, 03:26:44 PM »
[Hidden post: You need login to forum to see it.]

7
Feng Shui / Re: How much can you benefit from Feng Shui in apartment units?
« on: September 08, 2021, 08:55:55 AM »

Purple-White charts are annual charts, there is no static chart. In a landed property (single family residence) the P-W chart can be used to understand influences of any given year and sometime create very good charts (Pearl or Parent String charts for example) either by themselves or when mixed with the house's natal (Flying Star) chart (the annual stars can also mix with the natal chart to create good charts). The years that these good charts are formed are very good years to start on big projects and are therefore worth knowing.

For apartments or condos, all that you really have is the Purple White charts (the annual stars are already a part of the P-W system so you do not also look at the annual star - unlike what one would do in a landed property).

To respond to your second comment: The Flying Star charts are also influenced by the annual stars including the Purple-White charts, so whether a person practices Purple-White or Flying Stars they both can have recurring income.

Purple White has static charts, it's as good as the complicated replacement annual charts or probably better to due to its eases of use. Therefore to say purple white has no static charts is inaccurate.

8
The peculiar houses of sitting and facing SW or NE.

Feng Shui Exposé covered the topic of trapped prosperous star offered potential solutions. But I doubt your health issues are related to the trapped future prosperous star though.



While I sadly don't have the time to watch more of the material there, what I have seen so far seems very nice.

Most of his videos are below 10 mins, some even as short as 5. While I do not fancy the usage of XKFS but the man is doing it no holds bar. covering topics which people used to pay good money just to learn.

9
[Hidden post: You need 10 posts to see it. You currently have 0. Join the paid subscription and see this hidden post now.]

10
[Hidden post: You need 10 posts to see it. You currently have 0. Join the paid subscription and see this hidden post now.]

11
The peculiar houses of sitting and facing SW or NE.

Feng Shui Exposé covered the topic of trapped prosperous star offered potential solutions. But I doubt your health issues are related to the trapped future prosperous star though.


12
Request for divination [FREE] / Re: Kitchen feng shui
« on: August 24, 2021, 01:29:33 PM »
[Hidden post: You need login to forum to see it.]

New house or already staying there?

Any inhabitants with zodiac of Dog or Chicken?

The kitchen is least of the worries to be honest, if the the living room / dining room are surrounded by see glass sliding doors with perfect visibility of the jacuzzi & swimming pool.

New House that has yet to be built.  :)

Yes, 2 adult female dogs, Chicken is a kid.  (we have adult dogs, tiger, sheep, horses, monkey and kids of ox pig and rooster)

Wife Kua 6. Husband 4.

Just having thoughts on where is the best direction to place the kitchen stove...There will be 2 stoves.  One in the Dirty Kitchen and other one in the Clean Kitchen.  Confused on where the cook should be facing. and stove should be facing.  ::)

Also for the stairs,  any insights?

If you can then both stove move it to the left side, now it's sitting south facing north, move it to sitting eat facing west. Aside from this i doubt there's much you can do with the existing layout shown on the floorplan.

Basing on the attached 4 diagrams, Sitting East Facing West is "C", am I correct?

How about the stairs?  Is the location ok? or do we have to move it?

Yes C, can you actually move it without doing much to the existing layout?

My 2 cents worth is that for a house of such size, i would suggest that you hire a professional FS practitioner on site to take a look, since you are building from scratch, you have the luxury to built it in accordance to the surrounding landform to be honest. Even more so when you decided to have a swimming pool. Water is a tricky thing coz when time comes it can turn from good to bad almost immediately.

13
Request for divination [FREE] / Re: Kitchen feng shui
« on: August 24, 2021, 11:39:41 AM »
[Hidden post: You need login to forum to see it.]

New house or already staying there?

Any inhabitants with zodiac of Dog or Chicken?

The kitchen is least of the worries to be honest, if the the living room / dining room are surrounded by see glass sliding doors with perfect visibility of the jacuzzi & swimming pool.

New House that has yet to be built.  :)

Yes, 2 adult female dogs, Chicken is a kid.  (we have adult dogs, tiger, sheep, horses, monkey and kids of ox pig and rooster)

Wife Kua 6. Husband 4.

Just having thoughts on where is the best direction to place the kitchen stove...There will be 2 stoves.  One in the Dirty Kitchen and other one in the Clean Kitchen.  Confused on where the cook should be facing. and stove should be facing.  ::)

Also for the stairs,  any insights?

If you can then both stove move it to the left side, now it's sitting south facing north, move it to sitting eat facing west. Aside from this i doubt there's much you can do with the existing layout shown on the floorplan.

14
Request for divination [FREE] / Re: Kitchen feng shui
« on: August 23, 2021, 02:50:20 PM »
[Hidden post: You need login to forum to see it.]

15
Like I always said you just need the appropriate landform to harness sheng qi, need not complicated hocus pocus inducing formulas, you can't generate electricity trough the windmill without wind or through the solar panel on a cloudy day, simple as that.

So again no wind no electricity then the problem is the wind, no Qi no replenishment then the illness would not heal right? Ppl find 101 ways to avoid or cure the 5 yellow but this crazy guy actually went and purposely activate it and it seems he live to tell the tale? So tell me how much weight is in the image alone without Qi?
I think you are viewing Qi as something very different then how I'm viewing it. But in the way you view it, most of what Internal Alchemy and higher level Qi Gong practices do, would be impossible, as instead of just doing practices working and transforming, merging and fusing or spliting Qi, we would need to go near a mountain, and position ourselves at the correct incoming point to harness it,as that seems to be the only way to get Qi in your view...

We have done heavy renovation work on a place with 5 yellow. I have lived in a room with 5,2 People close to me are living in 5-5 and all is possible to work around, balance even renovate if we know how.

As far as the renovation on 5, we didn't had big problems, although if one has practiced systems for feeling the Qi its easy to notice something isn't right, after. But there are also easy ways to clear it(for us back then was as easy as throw a glass of water on the floor, complex to explain why and may sound silly, but it was what it was).

Then one day I messed up the calculation and after renovation at that same place at the next night the washing machine flooded  parts of the house(with perfect alignment with the Images of the stars there, as the other star was Water). Overall its delicate work that is also very precise in nature.

Of course, if you just calculate 5 yellow and nail something on the wall, that doesn't prove or disprove anything. Would be like feeling a pain on the right, imagine that is your liver and start to drink heavy medication for liver. Its not very logical, very simple and with not much meaning in it.

As it may be a real problem there. It also may not be. But with so simplistic approach nothing can be proven... Even less disproven as I never said people shouldn't hammer nails in any place with 5 yellow, so whatever he is disproving isn't very connected to the way I perceive the system. As in my view, the system is a lot more complicated, there are many factors that interplay and as already said, without understanding Yi Jing in some depth there isn't much one can do.

About the harnessing Qi... Well, use what you want, again  - the reply wasn't aimed at you, as we can't really say much to each other. You aren't interested in the systems I mostly write about, as that is San Yuan part of Feng Shui. Even though very rarely, lately.
 I have some interest in San He,  I think in some aspects its very good set of systems on its own, although entirely different then Flying Star and the others, but since the material that I like there is expensive, doesn't seem fair to the people teaching it to write much about it in the open. So I avoid writing about San He,you have no interest in anything else...
Then there is nothing we can say to each other at this point.

Xuan Kong is but a small subset of SanYuan, and when comes to landform, there are little to no dispute between SanYuan & SanHe, one measures Qi where it begins, another where it ends being the differentiation.

To say I'm not interested in SanYuan is a gross misconception for I'm a Zhong He practitioner to begin with, I just do not practice the XK flavour of SanYuan but that doesn't mean I do not practice SanYuan. I prefer harnessing earth qi more than chasing after luck.

Pages: [1] 2 3 ... 17

Disclaimer:

Your use of FiveArts.Info is at your sole risk. FiveArts.Info cannot be held responsible for the inaccuracy of the readings and information provided by its members.  FiveArts.Info owners, administrators, moderators, masters, members, partners expressly disclaim all warranties of any kind whether express or implied including but not limited to the implied warranties of merchantability or fitness for a particular purpose.




Total visits since 2014: